
It’s no big secret that I loves me some David Letterman. I’ve been a big fan of his since his first days at NBC, when I was a teenager and staying up until 12:30 on a school night to catch his irreverent show was a big deal for me, and I remember being upset that he wasn’t offered The Tonight Show after Johnny Carson left. I can look over at my bookshelf and see a copy of The Late Shift, chronicling the behind-the-scenes story of the late night wars. And it isn’t like nobody knew that there was a bit of friction between Dave and his late-night rival, Jay Leno, who ended up with the coveted chair at NBC. Well, in the twilight of Jay’s day behind the big desk, Dave gets a bit philosophical on just why Jay is leaving:
“Unless I’m misunderstanding something, I don’t know why, after the job Jay has done for them, why they would relinquish that,” Mr. Letterman said in the interview. “I guess they thought it was a less messy way to handle what happened to me at NBC. I don’t know.”
Mr. Letterman famously moved from NBC to CBS in 1993 after Mr. Leno replaced Johnny Carson on NBC’s “Tonight” show, establishing one of the foremost rivalries on television. Asked by the interviewer Jason Gay whether he empathizes with Mr. Leno’s situation, Mr. Letterman said: “I guess empathy is the right word. It’s hard to know what he felt about it. I have to believe he was not happy about it.” [...]
In the interview Mr. Letterman spends more time talking about the succession plan at NBC than he does his own future. Mr. Leno’s last edition of “Tonight” is scheduled for May 29, 2009. Mr. O’Brien is expected to take over on June 1. Mr. Letterman apparently harbored doubts about whether his former network would go forward with the plan. “I’m not quite sure why they would do that, so much so that one wonders if that’s actually what’s going to happen,” he said, later adding that it “just seemed so preposterous to me.”
But NBC reaffirmed the plans in May with the hiring of Jimmy Fallon as the future host of Mr. O’Brien’s “Late Night.”
“It’s only until recently that I felt this thing had traction,” Mr. Letterman said. [...]

For a while there, Dave insisted that CBS was not giving him a strong enough lead-in with their local broadcasts, and that is why he lagged behind in the ratings. However, he has a bit of a different approach to it now:
Mr. Letterman has ranked No. 2 behind Mr. Leno, who is 58, for more than a decade. Mr. Letterman acknowledges in the article, “I wish that we — and when I say ‘we’ I mean ‘me’ — I wish I could have prevailed.” But he concludes by saying that the reason for the ratings lies not in the local-news lead-ins of the two networks or the promotions of their shows, but in the difference between the two men. “I think he has greater appeal for more people than I do,” he said simply.
So far this season Mr. Leno’s “Tonight” show has averaged an audience of 4.8 million, while Mr. Letterman’s “Late Show” has averaged 3.5 million.
“It seems unlikely that now, after years and years of trying under a wide variety of circumstances and advantages and disadvantages, that suddenly I’m going to prevail,” Mr. Letterman said. “You can’t go through life fooling yourself. You have to be honest with the situation. That’s fine.”
That said, next year’s transition on NBC may present a new opportunity for Mr. Letterman. He told Rolling Stone that he had not given much thought to the forthcoming competition with Mr. O’Brien because “I still find it hard to believe that Jay won’t be there.”
And I think that is the crux of it right there. Jay is more acceptable to everyone…he doesn’t offend, he doesn’t push the envelope, he pretty much plays it safe. He’s very much the cheeseburger of late night television. Dave, however, is more like rattlesnake…very much an acquired taste, but those who like it really like it. I believe Conan’s humor is similar to Dave’s, because it sure isn’t anything like Jay Leno’s. It will be interesting to see how this plays out. Both Dave and Jay have great bands, however, so that should be interesting to follow.

In the meantime, Dave has done what I thought would be the unthinkable…he has offered a seat to Jay Leno:
“I think he’d be a great guest on the show. The first night that he is out of a job, I think that would be a great situation.”
Now that would be cool. To have Jay on Letterman’s show the first night of Conan’s show…well, that would be a huge coup for CBS. I hope they can work it out. I also hope that Dave can visit Jay’s show before he gives up the chair. It’s great to see these two, who battled for so long, finally come to a place in their lives where this is possible.
Besides, it’s my opinion that it’s still Johnny’s chair, Jay has just tried to fill it all these years. And I really don’t think that Conan can do it. He’s funny in his own way, but he’s not Tonight Show funny. So come on, Dave and Jay…bury the hatchet, and not in each other’s backs. That would be the most fitting end to Johnny’s legacy.